The following table shows the mayors of Conway. Mayors are numbered based on the actual election. Mayors elected multiple times in non-consecutive years are counted more than once. Acting mayors are not counted as official mayors because they were appointed by City Council, not elected by the public.

#NameYears ServedNotation
1Lorenzo D. Pearle, M.D.1875-1876
2E.C. Farmer1876-1877
3Capt. Edward Munroe Merriman1877-1878
4Able F. Livingston1879-1880
5George W. Bruce1880-1881
6John N. Walton1881-1882
7John Harrod1882-1883
8Homer G. Case1883-1884
9John Allen Pence1885Resigned
10Homer G. Case1885-1886
11John Ingram1886-1887
12Asa P. Robinson1887-1888
13W. G. Farmer1888-1889
14George W. Rice1889-1890
15William W. Martin1890-1894Resigned
16John T. Young1895-1896
17William W. Martin1896-1898
18John Allen Pence1899-1900
19William W. Martin1900-1901
20E.A. Bolton1901-1902
21William W. Martin1902-1905
W.H. Martin, acting1905Acting Mayor June 27 - July 3, 1905
22Frank E. Robins1906-1908Resigned
Opie Hartje, acting1908Acting Mayor Oct. 7 - Oct. 28, 1908
23A. J. Witt1909-1910
24W.H. Duncan1910-1913
25Frank Jones1914-1915
26J. C. Dawson1916-1917
27George W. Bruce1918Died in office
George Shaw, acting1918-1919Acting Mayor Nov. 11, 1918 - Nov. 30, 1919
28W.D. Cole1920-1925
29H.D. Russell1926-1933Resigned
Fred Gordy, acting1933Acting Mayor March 29, 1933 - April 11, 1933
30B.G. Wilson1933-1939Died in office
S.T. Smith, acting1939Acting Mayor July 11, 1939 - Oct. 17, 1939
31Alph Hamburg1939-1941
32James J. Kane1941-1944Leave of absence for active duty
33George Muse1944-1949Acting Mayor April 18, 1944; Elected April 10, 1945
34Edgar B. Parker1949-1954
35M.M. Satterfield1954-1957
36Edgar B. Parker1957-1961
37Walter Dunaway1962-1974
38Jim A. Hoggard1975-1978
39Bill Wright1979-1986
40David G. Kinley1987-1998
41Tab Townsell1999-2016
42Bart Castleberry2017-